Grumpy Muffin

Grumpy Muffin

  • Entertainment
  • Food & Drink
  • For Her
  • For Him
  • Personalized
  • Special Occasions
  • Sports
  • Search

2nd Anniversary

HomeSpecial OccasionsWedding Anniversary2nd Anniversary

2nd Anniversary

Two years in is a weird and specific time to buy someone a gift for. Your first anniversary has its own ceremony to it, and further along the road the milestones do the heavy lifting for you. But two years lands softly in between feeling big without actually being all that exciting to celebrate. Coming up with something worthy of the moment means thinking harder than most will. As it happens, the traditional material to celebrate two years of anything is cotton. Listen how that sounds. Cotton. It’s the sort of trivia that you google and then promptly disregard because you’re now left wondering what in the world to actually buy with that information. But we’d argue there’s something to take seriously here, because cotton represents all of the cozy minutiae that makes a life shared with another person. Sheet sets you spent countless nights burrowing into together. The soft faded fabric of a lovedy that’s been well worn from too much use and not enough washing. If feels like it was made for two years together. And so we started with cotton, and built out from there. Some of our finds dig into that tradition with earnest, providing cotton-y gifts done right. Other products we came across are cotton all metaphor, embracing less the material and more the feeling of what two years actually is. To that end it’s comfortable. Really comfortable. Two people who have figured out that they like each other well enough to not have to pretend all the time. Who’ve settled into each other’s lives and become...routine, and loved it. We wanted gifts that reflected all of that. We weren’t going for sparkle here. Two years isn’t the time for those kinds of gestures. But it is the place for little nods that say you were paying attention. Things that matter enough to hit their mark but are also well thought out enough to not scare anyone away. This is two years. The gifts we’ve included here are ones we’d buy for the people in our lives if we were standing in your shoes right now. Everything else we just didn’t trust. Some things we loved were too impersonal. Stunningly gorgeous, but sterile. Perfect for an instagram post but will likely stay boxed for “best”. We didn’t include those. Some were too lightweight. Sweet, but not quite to the level that feels like it’s marking a second anniversary. What you’re left with is our best bets. The short list of gifts we actually trust to get right. Because that’s really the only list worth publishing.
  • All Products
  • Hot Products
  • New Products
  • Sale Products
  • 50 products Showing all 50 results

  • 1954 What a Year It Was!: Birthday or Anniversary Gift – Coffee Table Book 2nd edition
    Buy Now

    1954 What a Year It Was!: Birthday or Anniversary Gift – Coffee Table Book 2nd edition

    $10.15
  • 1pc Romantic 2nd Anniversary Greeting Card With Envelope – “2 Years Later” Sweet Message, Perfect For Him Or Her, Creative Wedding Anniversary Gift Id41%
    Buy Now

    1pc Romantic 2nd Anniversary Greeting Card With Envelope – “2 Years Later” Sweet Message, Perfect For Him Or Her, Creative Wedding Anniversary Gift Id

    $1.90 Original price was: $1.90.$1.13Current price is: $1.13.
  • 2 Year Anniversary Traditional Gifts for Her Him 2nd Anniversary Romantic Gifts for Her Second Year Cotton Anniversary Wedding Gift Happy Anniversary Blanket Decorations Present for Girlfriend11%
    Buy Now

    2 Year Anniversary Traditional Gifts for Her Him 2nd Anniversary Romantic Gifts for Her Second Year Cotton Anniversary Wedding Gift Happy Anniversary Blanket Decorations Present for Girlfriend

    $26.99 Original price was: $26.99.$23.99Current price is: $23.99.
  • 2 Year Yr Anniversary Personalized Gifts for Him Husband Her Men Happy 2nd Wedding Anniversary Engraved Wallet Card Gift for Wife Women Boyfriend
    Buy Now

    2 Year Yr Anniversary Personalized Gifts for Him Husband Her Men Happy 2nd Wedding Anniversary Engraved Wallet Card Gift for Wife Women Boyfriend

    $9.94
  • 2 Years Anniversary Acrylic Gift for Him or Her Cotton Flower Drawing Print Acrylic Decor 2nd Anniversary Wedding Paperweight Second Year Marriage for Wife Husband Lover(Flower Style)19%
    Buy Now

    2 Years Anniversary Acrylic Gift for Him or Her Cotton Flower Drawing Print Acrylic Decor 2nd Anniversary Wedding Paperweight Second Year Marriage for Wife Husband Lover(Flower Style)

    $24.81 Original price was: $24.81.$20.21Current price is: $20.21.
  • 2 Years Anniversary Blanket Gifts for Men Women 2nd Anniversary Cotton Gifts for Boyfriend Girlfriend Wedding Anniversary Blanket Gifts for Husband Wife Couple Happy Anniversary for Couple Christmas
    Buy Now

    2 Years Anniversary Blanket Gifts for Men Women 2nd Anniversary Cotton Gifts for Boyfriend Girlfriend Wedding Anniversary Blanket Gifts for Husband Wife Couple Happy Anniversary for Couple Christmas

    $25.99
  • 2 Years Anniversary Blanket Gifts for Women Men 2nd Anniversary Cotton Gifts for Her Girlfriend Wedding Anniversary Blanket Gifts for Husband Wife Christmas Happy Anniversary for Couple 50×60
    Buy Now

    2 Years Anniversary Blanket Gifts for Women Men 2nd Anniversary Cotton Gifts for Her Girlfriend Wedding Anniversary Blanket Gifts for Husband Wife Christmas Happy Anniversary for Couple 50×60

    $25.99
  • 2nd Anniversary 2 Years In And She Hasn t Killed Me Yet T-Shirt15%
    Buy Now

    2nd Anniversary 2 Years In And She Hasn t Killed Me Yet T-Shirt

    $13.99 Original price was: $13.99.$11.89Current price is: $11.89.
  • 2nd Anniversary Bracelet for Husband from Wife 2023 2 Years Anniversary
    Buy Now

    2nd Anniversary Bracelet for Husband from Wife 2023 2 Years Anniversary

    $29.99
  • 2nd Anniversary Bracelet for Husband Wife Him Her 2024 2 Years Anniversary
    Buy Now

    2nd Anniversary Bracelet for Husband Wife Him Her 2024 2 Years Anniversary

    $29.99
  • 2nd Anniversary Card – Cotton Theme Greeting Card with Yarn Spool Design – Includes Red Envelope – Perfect for Celebrating Paper Anniversary
    Buy Now

    2nd Anniversary Card – Cotton Theme Greeting Card with Yarn Spool Design – Includes Red Envelope – Perfect for Celebrating Paper Anniversary

    $9.99
  • 2nd Anniversary His Her Boyfriend Girlfriend Cotton 2nd Anniversary Wedding Gift Husband Wife Best 2nd Anniversary Couple Matching Keychain Level 2 Complete Valentine s Day Gift
    Buy Now

    2nd Anniversary His Her Boyfriend Girlfriend Cotton 2nd Anniversary Wedding Gift Husband Wife Best 2nd Anniversary Couple Matching Keychain Level 2 Complete Valentine s Day Gift

    $12.98
  • 2nd Anniversary Keychain for Husband Wife Him Her 2 Years of Marriage Couples Key Chain
    Buy Now

    2nd Anniversary Keychain for Husband Wife Him Her 2 Years of Marriage Couples Key Chain

    $24.99
  • 2nd Anniversary Picture Frame Holds Two 4×6 Photos Rustic Wood
    Buy Now

    2nd Anniversary Picture Frame Holds Two 4×6 Photos Rustic Wood

    $41.78
  • 2nd Anniversary Picture Frame Wood Photo Frames 4 x 6 Engraved Display Wooden Tabletop Postcard Frame for Hanging Wall Gallery Girlfriend Wife Valentine s Day 2 Years of Marriage Gifts
    Buy Now

    2nd Anniversary Picture Frame Wood Photo Frames 4 x 6 Engraved Display Wooden Tabletop Postcard Frame for Hanging Wall Gallery Girlfriend Wife Valentine s Day 2 Years of Marriage Gifts

    $16.65
  • 2nd Anniversary Sterling Silver Locket Pendant & 18″ Box Chain With Verse Inscription61%
    Buy Now

    2nd Anniversary Sterling Silver Locket Pendant & 18″ Box Chain With Verse Inscription

    $206.99 Original price was: $206.99.$79.99Current price is: $79.99.
  • 2nd Years Wedding Anniversary Gifts For Couples Matching T-Shirt
    Buy Now

    2nd Years Wedding Anniversary Gifts For Couples Matching T-Shirt

    $11.00
  • 3drose 2 Years of Marriage 2nd Wedding Anniversary in Months Days Hours 13×13 Wall Clock
    Buy Now

    3drose 2 Years of Marriage 2nd Wedding Anniversary in Months Days Hours 13×13 Wall Clock

    $42.99
  • 3drose 2 Years of Marriage 2nd Wedding Anniversary in Months Days Hours 15oz Two-tone Green Mug
    Buy Now

    3drose 2 Years of Marriage 2nd Wedding Anniversary in Months Days Hours 15oz Two-tone Green Mug

    $16.76
  • 3drose 2 Years of Marriage 2nd Wedding Anniversary in Months Days Hours 16×16 inch Pillow Case
    Buy Now

    3drose 2 Years of Marriage 2nd Wedding Anniversary in Months Days Hours 16×16 inch Pillow Case

    $8.99
  • 5pcs IL.LIT, ILT, ILL, GLLIT, 2nd Debut Anniversary, Special Bonus Card, Special Album Card, Special Bonus Cards, Fans Merchandise, Idol Merchandise G7%
    Buy Now

    5pcs IL.LIT, ILT, ILL, GLLIT, 2nd Debut Anniversary, Special Bonus Card, Special Album Card, Special Bonus Cards, Fans Merchandise, Idol Merchandise G

    $4.00 Original price was: $4.00.$3.73Current price is: $3.73.
  • 9 year anniversary gift. Pottery anniversary. 1st anniversary gift for husband. 2nd anniversary gift. 11th anniversary
    Buy Now

    9 year anniversary gift. Pottery anniversary. 1st anniversary gift for husband. 2nd anniversary gift. 11th anniversary

    $23.03
  • Anniversary Blanket for Him Her Couples Blanket Wedding Throw Blanket for Women Men Anniversary Marriage Gifts for Wife Husband Anniversary Decorations Cotton Gifts for 2nd Anniversary 50×60
    Buy Now

    Anniversary Blanket for Him Her Couples Blanket Wedding Throw Blanket for Women Men Anniversary Marriage Gifts for Wife Husband Anniversary Decorations Cotton Gifts for 2nd Anniversary 50×60

    $25.99
  • BA/BYMONSTER 2nd Anniversary Era2 Commemorative Full Set Photocards, “Era 2: 2ND ANNIVERSARY” Full Set Lomo Photocards, Ruka/Pharita/Asa/Ahyeon/Rami/R5%
    Buy Now

    BA/BYMONSTER 2nd Anniversary Era2 Commemorative Full Set Photocards, “Era 2: 2ND ANNIVERSARY” Full Set Lomo Photocards, Ruka/Pharita/Asa/Ahyeon/Rami/R

    $2.80 Original price was: $2.80.$2.66Current price is: $2.66.
  • CafePress – 2Nd Anniversary Dog Years Pajamas – Men s Dark Loose Fit Cotton Pajama Set
    Buy Now

    CafePress – 2Nd Anniversary Dog Years Pajamas – Men s Dark Loose Fit Cotton Pajama Set

    $44.98
  • CafePress – 2Nd Anniversary Funny Quote – Men s Light Pajamas
    Buy Now

    CafePress – 2Nd Anniversary Funny Quote – Men s Light Pajamas

    $44.98
  • CafePress – 2Nd Anniversary Funny Quote – Women s Light Pajamas
    Buy Now

    CafePress – 2Nd Anniversary Funny Quote – Women s Light Pajamas

    $44.98
  • CafePress – 2Nd Anniversary Funny Quote Women s Light Pajamas – Women s Short Sleeve Print T-Shirt and Pants Light Cotton Pajama Set
    Buy Now

    CafePress – 2Nd Anniversary Funny Quote Women s Light Pajamas – Women s Short Sleeve Print T-Shirt and Pants Light Cotton Pajama Set

    $44.98
  • CafePress – 2Nd Anniversary Funny Quote Women s T Shirt – Women s Classic T-Shirt
    Buy Now

    CafePress – 2Nd Anniversary Funny Quote Women s T Shirt – Women s Classic T-Shirt

    $22.99
  • Cotton Anniversary Card – Marriage Material Pun with Adorable Spools Design – Perfect for 2nd Wedding Anniversary Celebration
    Buy Now

    Cotton Anniversary Card – Marriage Material Pun with Adorable Spools Design – Perfect for 2nd Wedding Anniversary Celebration

    $9.99
  • Cotton Boll Christmas Ornament 2nd Wedding Anniversary Cotton Boll ACRYLIC Suncatcher Cotton Boll Window Decor Housewarming Gift For Her
    Buy Now

    Cotton Boll Christmas Ornament 2nd Wedding Anniversary Cotton Boll ACRYLIC Suncatcher Cotton Boll Window Decor Housewarming Gift For Her

    $25.79
  • Couples Second Anniversary gift 2nd Wedding Anniversary T-Shirt1%
    Buy Now

    Couples Second Anniversary gift 2nd Wedding Anniversary T-Shirt

    $13.99 Original price was: $13.99.$13.89Current price is: $13.89.
  • Custom Embroidered Wedding Blanket/Wedding Gift/Personalized Wedding Present/Engagement Gift/2nd Anniversary Present
    Buy Now

    Custom Embroidered Wedding Blanket/Wedding Gift/Personalized Wedding Present/Engagement Gift/2nd Anniversary Present

    $85.00
  • Daisyco Gifts Custom Photo Metal Wallet Card Personalized 1st 2nd 5th Anniversary Aluminum Gift For Husband
    Buy Now

    Daisyco Gifts Custom Photo Metal Wallet Card Personalized 1st 2nd 5th Anniversary Aluminum Gift For Husband

    $17.99
  • Happy 2nd Anniversary! Two Hearts as One Volume One: Anniversary gifts for her for him for couple anniversary rings (Paperback)
    Buy Now

    Happy 2nd Anniversary! Two Hearts as One Volume One: Anniversary gifts for her for him for couple anniversary rings (Paperback)

    $12.75
  • Happy 2nd Anniversary! Two Hearts as One Volume One: Anniversary gifts for her, for him, for couple, anniversary rings, in Women’s Fashion, in Novelty
    Buy Now

    Happy 2nd Anniversary! Two Hearts as One Volume One: Anniversary gifts for her, for him, for couple, anniversary rings, in Women’s Fashion, in Novelty

    $12.75
  • Henry Spirit of the Corps 250th Anniversary Tribute 2nd Edition .22 S/L/LR Nickel/Gold Plated Lever Action Rifle – 20in – Brown
    Buy Now

    Henry Spirit of the Corps 250th Anniversary Tribute 2nd Edition .22 S/L/LR Nickel/Gold Plated Lever Action Rifle – 20in – Brown

    $1,149.99
  • Level 2 Complete Retro 2nd Wedding Anniversary T-Shirt
    Buy Now

    Level 2 Complete Retro 2nd Wedding Anniversary T-Shirt

    $11.99
  • MEGA SPACE MOLLY 100% 2nd Anniversary Series Blind Box, Cute Pink Leopard Molly Figurine Decor, Astronaut Figurine Collection, Display Shelf Collectio40%
    Buy Now

    MEGA SPACE MOLLY 100% 2nd Anniversary Series Blind Box, Cute Pink Leopard Molly Figurine Decor, Astronaut Figurine Collection, Display Shelf Collectio

    $36.60 Original price was: $36.60.$21.86Current price is: $21.86.
  • Naixiwen Funny 2 Years Anniversary Card, Two Years Anniversary Card For Husband Wife, Happy 2nd Wedding Anniversary Card, Cotton Anniversary Card43%
    Buy Now

    Naixiwen Funny 2 Years Anniversary Card, Two Years Anniversary Card For Husband Wife, Happy 2nd Wedding Anniversary Card, Cotton Anniversary Card

    $9.80 Original price was: $9.80.$5.60Current price is: $5.60.
  • New 2Pcs/Set 2nd Anniversary Card Alien Stage TV Anime Card Ivan Till Cosplay Square CD Card Instant Imaging Cards Postcard Gift
    Buy Now

    New 2Pcs/Set 2nd Anniversary Card Alien Stage TV Anime Card Ivan Till Cosplay Square CD Card Instant Imaging Cards Postcard Gift

    $4.41
  • Our 2nd Anniversary Christmas Ornament 2023 Rose Porcelain Ornament Husband Wife Rustic Wood and Roses
    Buy Now

    Our 2nd Anniversary Christmas Ornament 2023 Rose Porcelain Ornament Husband Wife Rustic Wood and Roses

    $16.98
  • Our Second Christmas As Mr & Mrs Ornament Personalized Name & Year Couple Ornament Christmas 2025 Customized 2nd Xmas Married Ornament Gifts for Husband & Wife Custom Anniversary Ornament puS2IP
    Buy Now

    Our Second Christmas As Mr & Mrs Ornament Personalized Name & Year Couple Ornament Christmas 2025 Customized 2nd Xmas Married Ornament Gifts for Husband & Wife Custom Anniversary Ornament puS2IP

    $18.99
  • Personalised Song Sheet Music Notes Lyrics Print 1st, 2nd Anniversary, Wedding, First Dance, Couple Gift Unframed, Framed Or Canvas
    Buy Now

    Personalised Song Sheet Music Notes Lyrics Print 1st, 2nd Anniversary, Wedding, First Dance, Couple Gift Unframed, Framed Or Canvas

    $33.52
  • Pre-Owned 2nd Anniversary Sterling Silver Locket Pendant & 18″ Box Chain With Verse Inscription40%
    Buy Now

    Pre-Owned 2nd Anniversary Sterling Silver Locket Pendant & 18″ Box Chain With Verse Inscription

    $206.99 Original price was: $206.99.$124.99Current price is: $124.99.
  • sassyy.af: 2nd Anniversary Gift For Wife – Blank Composition Notebook & Journal To Write In Notes About Hubbie (Paperback)
    Buy Now

    sassyy.af: 2nd Anniversary Gift For Wife – Blank Composition Notebook & Journal To Write In Notes About Hubbie (Paperback)

    $8.97
  • Sex After Your 2nd Anniversary (Chinese Edition) (Paperback)
    Buy Now

    Sex After Your 2nd Anniversary (Chinese Edition) (Paperback)

    $9.97
  • Sex After Your 2nd Anniversary (Paperback)
    Buy Now

    Sex After Your 2nd Anniversary (Paperback)

    $9.97
  • The Good Old Days Are Being Made Now Sign With Personalized Name for New Home, Wedding, Anniversary, or Couples Gift **FREE 2nd DAY Air
    Buy Now

    The Good Old Days Are Being Made Now Sign With Personalized Name for New Home, Wedding, Anniversary, or Couples Gift **FREE 2nd DAY Air

    $47.99
  • USA Push Pin Travel Map: 2nd Anniversary Cotton Gift, US Map, No Title
    Buy Now

    USA Push Pin Travel Map: 2nd Anniversary Cotton Gift, US Map, No Title

    $75.00
Copyright © 2026
Go to top
Close

Search

View more
Close

My Account

Login

Lost your password?

Close

Cart

Shopping Cart 0

No products in the basket.

Close

Product Quick View

  • Entertainment
  • Food & Drink
  • For Her
  • For Him
  • Personalized
  • Special Occasions
  • Sports
  • Shopping Cart 0
  • Login